Psychological First Aid vs Mental Health First Aid: Which Does Your Company Need?

Understanding the Difference

Both approaches support mental wellbeing but serve different purposes in the workplace. Understanding when to apply each can significantly enhance your organization's ability to support employees.

Psychological First Aid (PFA)

• Purpose: Immediate support following traumatic events or crises
• Training: 4-8 hours focused on crisis response protocols
• Timing: Reactive – deployed during or immediately after incidents
• Focus: Reducing acute distress and stabilizing affected individuals
• Scope: Addresses trauma directly related to specific incidents

Mental Health First Aid (MHFA)

• Purpose: Recognizing and responding to signs of mental health challenges
• Training: 8-12 hours covering various mental health conditions
• Timing: Proactive – applied in everyday situations before crises occur
• Focus: Building mental health literacy and providing initial support
• Scope: Addresses broader spectrum of mental health conditions

When to Use Each Approach

Use PFA During:

• Organizational crises (layoffs, restructuring)
• Workplace incidents or accidents
• External disasters affecting employees
• Loss of colleagues or team traumas

Use MHFA For:

• Building preventative workplace culture
• Addressing ongoing mental health challenges
• Supporting diverse workforce needs
• Reducing stigma and building mental health literacy

The Integrated Approach: Using Both

Many forward-thinking organizations implement both approaches for comprehensive support:

Everyday Support

MHFA-trained employees recognize early warning signs and provide initial guidance

Crisis Response

PFA-trained teams mobilize during specific incidents requiring immediate intervention

Seamless Continuity

Integration between crisis management and long-term support for complete care

ROI of Mental Health Support

$4

For every $1 invested in treatment for common mental disorders, there is a $4 return in improved health and productivity.

Source: World Health Organization

Making the Right Choice

The decision between implementing PFA, MHFA, or both approaches should be guided by your organization's specific needs, culture, and resources.

Need help determining the right approach for your organization?

Contact iGrowFit Today

Helping businesses develop their people to "Hit Goals and Finish Tasks" consistently

Understanding Mental Health Support in the Workplace

The landscape of workplace mental health has transformed dramatically in recent years. What was once considered a personal matter outside the scope of employer responsibility has now become recognized as a crucial element of organizational health and performance. Research consistently shows that mentally healthy workplaces experience higher productivity, lower absenteeism, reduced turnover, and stronger employee engagement.

According to the World Health Organization, for every $1 invested in scaled-up treatment for common mental disorders, there is a return of $4 in improved health and productivity. This compelling return on investment has prompted forward-thinking organizations to implement structured approaches to mental health support—with Psychological First Aid and Mental Health First Aid emerging as two of the most widely adopted frameworks.

Before diving into the specifics of each approach, it's important to understand that mental health support exists on a spectrum. At one end are preventative measures and everyday wellbeing practices; at the other are clinical interventions for diagnosed conditions. PFA and MHFA occupy different positions on this spectrum, making them suitable for different scenarios and objectives.

What is Psychological First Aid (PFA)?

Psychological First Aid is an evidence-based approach designed to provide immediate support to individuals who have experienced a traumatic event or crisis. Originally developed for disaster response situations, PFA has been adapted for various contexts, including workplace incidents and organizational crises.

The core objective of PFA is not to provide therapy or counseling but rather to offer practical, non-intrusive support that promotes natural recovery processes. It focuses on reducing initial distress, addressing basic needs, and facilitating access to additional support when necessary.

The World Health Organization's PFA framework consists of eight core actions:

1. Contact and engagement - Establishing a compassionate connection with affected individuals
2. Safety and comfort - Ensuring physical and emotional safety
3. Stabilization - Calming overwhelmed or disoriented individuals
4. Information gathering - Understanding immediate needs and concerns
5. Practical assistance - Helping address basic needs and solving practical problems
6. Connection with social supports - Facilitating contact with support systems
7. Information on coping - Providing information on stress reactions and coping strategies
8. Linkage with collaborative services - Connecting individuals with needed services

In a workplace context, PFA might be deployed following a workplace accident, during organizational restructuring that creates significant anxiety, after the unexpected loss of a colleague, or during any situation that creates acute psychological distress among employees.

What is Mental Health First Aid (MHFA)?

Mental Health First Aid, in contrast to PFA, is a training program designed to equip individuals with the skills to recognize and respond to signs of mental health challenges and substance use disorders. Developed in Australia in 2000 and now implemented globally, MHFA is often compared to traditional first aid but for mental health conditions.

MHFA training teaches participants to identify, understand, and respond to signs of mental illnesses and substance use disorders. The program uses the ALGEE action plan as its core framework:

1. Assess for risk of suicide or harm
2. Listen non-judgmentally
3. Give reassurance and information
4. Encourage appropriate professional help
5. Encourage self-help and other support strategies

Unlike PFA, which is primarily focused on immediate crisis response, MHFA is designed to address a broader range of mental health situations, including ongoing conditions like depression, anxiety disorders, psychosis, and substance use problems. MHFA is preventative and educational in nature, equipping employees with the knowledge to recognize early warning signs and provide appropriate initial support before a crisis point is reached.

In organizations, MHFA-trained employees serve as an informal first line of support, creating a culture where mental health challenges are recognized early and addressed appropriately, potentially preventing escalation to more serious conditions.

Key Differences Between PFA and MHFA

While both approaches support mental wellbeing, they differ in several key aspects:

Timing and Context

• PFA is designed for immediate deployment following a crisis or traumatic event. It's reactive and situation-specific.
• MHFA is more broadly applicable across various situations and timeframes, including both acute issues and chronic conditions. It's proactive and educational.

Training Requirements

• PFA training is typically shorter (often 4-8 hours) and focuses on specific response protocols for crisis situations.
• MHFA certification is more comprehensive (usually 8-12 hours) and covers a wider range of mental health conditions and appropriate responses.

Primary Objectives

• PFA aims to reduce acute distress, promote short-term coping, and link affected individuals to appropriate resources during or immediately after a crisis.
• MHFA focuses on recognizing emerging mental health issues, providing initial support, and guiding individuals toward appropriate professional help before crises occur.

Scope of Application

• PFA addresses trauma and distress directly related to specific incidents.
• MHFA covers a broader spectrum of mental health conditions, including depression, anxiety disorders, psychosis, and substance use disorders.

Delivery Model

• PFA is typically delivered by designated response teams or trained individuals during specific incidents.
• MHFA creates a network of trained employees throughout the organization who can recognize and respond to mental health issues as they arise in day-to-day operations.

When Should Companies Use Psychological First Aid?

Psychological First Aid is particularly valuable in scenarios involving acute distress or trauma. Consider implementing PFA in these situations:

Organizational Crises

During significant organizational changes such as large-scale layoffs, mergers, or restructuring that create acute anxiety and uncertainty among employees. PFA provides immediate support to help staff process their emotional responses and access appropriate resources.

Workplace Incidents

Following workplace accidents, violence, or other traumatic events that affect employees either directly or as witnesses. PFA helps prevent the development of longer-term psychological issues by addressing immediate distress.

External Disasters

When external events like natural disasters, terrorist attacks, or public health crises (such as the COVID-19 pandemic) impact your workforce. PFA offers structured support during community-wide trauma that inevitably affects workplace functioning.

Personal Crises Affecting Teams

When the sudden loss of a colleague or other significant personal events affect team cohesion and psychological safety. PFA provides a framework for supporting both individuals and the collective group.

The key indicator for PFA implementation is the presence of an acute, identifiable stressor that creates immediate psychological distress requiring prompt intervention.

When Should Companies Implement Mental Health First Aid?

Mental Health First Aid serves different purposes and is ideal in these scenarios:

Preventative Workplace Culture Development

When building a comprehensive mental health strategy focused on prevention rather than just crisis response. MHFA creates a foundation of awareness and support throughout the organization.

Addressing Ongoing Mental Health Challenges

In workplaces where employees may experience various mental health conditions that develop gradually rather than suddenly. MHFA equips colleagues to recognize warning signs and provide appropriate initial support.

Supporting Diverse Workforce Needs

In organizations with diverse employee populations who may experience different mental health challenges based on personal backgrounds, work responsibilities, or life circumstances. MHFA provides a broad framework applicable across various situations.

Building Mental Health Literacy

When organizational goals include reducing stigma around mental health and increasing overall understanding of psychological wellbeing. MHFA serves an educational function beyond just response protocols.

MHFA is particularly valuable as part of a long-term, sustainable approach to workplace mental health rather than as a rapid response to specific incidents.

Complementary Approaches: Using Both PFA and MHFA

Many forward-thinking organizations find that implementing both Psychological First Aid and Mental Health First Aid creates a comprehensive mental health support system that addresses both acute crises and ongoing wellbeing.

This integrated approach creates multiple layers of support:

1. Everyday support through MHFA-trained employees who recognize early warning signs and provide initial guidance
2. Crisis response through PFA-trained teams who can mobilize during specific incidents
3. Seamless continuity between crisis management and long-term support

For instance, an employee experiencing acute distress following an organizational restructuring announcement might receive immediate support through PFA protocols. Once the initial crisis period has passed, MHFA-trained colleagues can provide ongoing support as the employee adjusts to new circumstances, potentially preventing the development of more serious conditions like depression or anxiety disorders.

This complementary approach recognizes that mental health exists on a continuum and that organizations need different tools for different points on that continuum.

Implementation Considerations for Your Organization

When determining which approach—or combination of approaches—best suits your organization, consider these factors:

Organizational Risk Profile

Assess your industry and specific workplace for inherent risks that might necessitate crisis response. High-risk industries (construction, healthcare, emergency services) or organizations undergoing significant change may benefit more immediately from PFA capabilities.

Existing Support Structures

Evaluate your current mental health resources, including Employee Assistance Programs, health benefits, and workplace policies. Determine where gaps exist and which approach would best complement existing systems.

Organizational Culture

Consider your workplace culture and readiness for mental health initiatives. Some organizations may need to focus first on building basic mental health literacy (through MHFA) before implementing crisis response protocols.

Resource Allocation

Both approaches require investment in training and implementation. Consider your budget, timeline, and available personnel when deciding which to prioritize initially if implementing both simultaneously isn't feasible.

Measurement and Evaluation Plan

Determine how you'll measure success. Different metrics may be appropriate for PFA (such as crisis response effectiveness) versus MHFA (such as increased help-seeking behavior or reduced stigma).

Measuring the Impact of Mental Health Support Programs

Regardless of which approach you implement, measuring impact is essential for program sustainability and continued improvement.

Key performance indicators might include:

• Utilization rates of mental health resources and services
• Absenteeism and presenteeism metrics before and after implementation
• Employee engagement scores related to wellbeing and support
• Qualitative feedback from both program participants and recipients of support
• Return on investment calculations comparing program costs to benefits like reduced turnover or increased productivity

Establishing baseline measurements before implementation allows for meaningful comparison and demonstrates the business value of mental health support programs beyond their inherent human value.

Conclusion: Making the Right Choice for Your Company

The decision between implementing Psychological First Aid, Mental Health First Aid, or both approaches should be guided by your organization's specific needs, culture, and resources. Each framework offers distinct benefits and addresses different aspects of the mental health support spectrum.

Psychological First Aid provides a structured crisis response system for acute situations, helping employees navigate immediate distress following traumatic events or significant organizational changes. Mental Health First Aid, meanwhile, builds a foundation of mental health literacy and everyday support that can prevent many issues from reaching crisis level.

For most organizations, the ideal approach is not an either/or decision but rather a strategic integration of both frameworks into a comprehensive mental health support system. This multi-layered approach ensures employees receive appropriate support across the full spectrum of mental health needs—from preventative education to crisis response and recovery.

By thoughtfully implementing these evidence-based frameworks, your organization can create a workplace environment that genuinely supports employee wellbeing while simultaneously enhancing productivity, engagement, and retention. The investment in comprehensive mental health support not only fulfills an ethical responsibility to your team members but also delivers measurable business benefits that contribute to sustainable organizational success.

Ready to enhance your organization's mental health support systems? At iGrowFit, we specialize in developing customized employee assistance programs that integrate the most effective approaches to workplace mental wellbeing. Our team of psychologists, coaches, and consultants can help you determine which mental health support frameworks best align with your organizational needs and implement them effectively. Contact iGrowFit today to learn how we can help your company develop a comprehensive mental health strategy that supports both your people and your business goals.